Feb 28, 2025 | Blog, Issue Updates

Issue Alert! Alliance Submits Amicus Brief in Puget Sound Tidegate Lawsuit

The Family Farm Alliance joined four other state and national water organizations in an amicus curiae (“friend of the court”) brief that was submitted February 21 to the U.S. District Court of Western Washington in support of the Skagit County (WASHINGTON) Dike, Drainage and Irrigation District 12’s challenge of a biological opinion issued by National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) for the No Name Slough tidegate replacement project.

The case raises several important Endangered Species Act (ESA) issues and could set precedent for other water users in the Western U.S.

“This case has important implications for any entity with an existing structure that may require federal permits in the future for maintenance,” said Jenna Friebel, Executive Director of the Skagit Drainage and Irrigation Districts Consortium.

This case dates back to April 22, 2024, when NMFS issued a biological opinion (BO) finding that the District’s proposed tidegate replacement project would jeopardize the continued existence of the Puget Sound Chinook Salmon (“PS Chinook”) and southern resident Killer Whale (“SRKW”), and would likely adversely modify their critical habitat.

The District disagreed, and on December 13, 2024 filed its motion for summary judgment arguing the NMFS jeopardy opinion was a violation of the APA as “arbitrary and capricious” in that it violated its own regulations.

“The Project is a simple tidegate replacement that does not expand the footprint of the existing structures and provides benefits to fish compared to the status quo,” the District argued in its motion.

Tidegates are designed so that when the tide goes out, the gates swing open to release water from behind the dike, which allows fish in the Puget Sound to pass. When the tide comes in, the gates close to keep out seawater and prevent fish from entering the channels behind the dikes.

According to the District, NMFS erred in its BO by:

(1) defining the action area for an isolated tidegate replacement as all of Puget Sound;
(2) double counting the impacts of the tidegate in both the environmental baseline and effects of the action;
(3) attributing jeopardy in the baseline to the Project; and
(4) analyzing the effects of the Project as if the Project was occurring in natural conditions.

Importantly, the jeopardy and adverse modification conclusions for both the salmon and the orcas are dependent on the assumption that the proposed project would impair the habitat of the juvenile Skagit Chinook populations.

The District countered by noting that the tidegate exists today, the juvenile Chinook numbers are increasing, and the use of the area near the project by juvenile salmon is limited.

As a result, the District argues that the biological opinion fails to rationally evaluate the effects of the project and should be vacated and remanded to NMFS.

The Alliance amicus brief focuses on the proper legal standard for what deference a federal agency is entitled to for its scientific determinations when preparing opinions under the statute.

“We submitted this brief to provide the court with insights into legal standards governing the court’s review of an agency’s actions under the Administrative Procedures Act and, in particular, an agency’s scientific findings,” said Norm Semanko, the Alliance’s General Counsel. “The court does not owe NMFS either unlimited or automatic deference for its scientific determinations.”

Joining the amicus with the Alliance are the Washington State Water Resources Association, the Idaho Water Users Association, the National Water Resources Association and the Oregon Water Resources Congress.

Many of these organizations are directly impacted by NMFS’s regulatory decisions under the Endangered Species Act (“ESA”), particularly as these decisions relate to permitting and mitigation requirements affecting agricultural-based water uses that are critical to the wellbeing and financial success of the nation’s farmers and, by extension, the nation’s agricultural economy.

“In this case, NMFS completely neglected to discuss the precedents that dictate how courts may scrutinize an agency’s scientific findings,” said Mr. Semanko. “We are seeking to further inform the court on this matter,  and I believe we were successful in doing that.”